Monday, 7 October 2019

CONCEPT OF PRIMARY JUSTICE IN OUR JUDICIAL SYSTEM


CONCEPT OF PRIMARY JUSTICE IN
OUR JUDICIAL SYSTEM

By

Dr. Zafar Ahmed Khan Sherwani, Ph.D.(Law)1

Annual International Judicial Conference, 2013 was held from 19-21 April, by the Law and Justice Commission of Pakistan (LJCP) with the purpose to provide an opportunity to the stakeholders of justice sector to share experiences and evolve strategies for addressing the problems which are being faced by the judicial system. The declaration of the conference issued on the conclusion includes the recommendations of the group on Alternative Dispute Resolution, (ADR) which inter alia says that the "Lok Adalat" system as introduced and developed in India should be examined to see how it can be used for our mutual benefit and the ADR mechanisms already available in the law should be highlighted and fully enforced.

The Supreme Court is conscious of the huge pendency of cases before the courts of the country. It is an uphill task for a common man to get justice from courts in a speedy and inexpensive way. It's one of the responsibilities of every democratic polity to provide quick and inexpensive mechanism for dispute resolution for its people. Cropping of disputes amongst members of any society is a human phenomenon. Quick and inexpensive resolution of such dispute shave strong nexus with good governance. EveryState is responsible to provide aframe work to its government to cater for their need of quick and inexpensive dispute resolution, which should match their cultural and traditional mindset and universally accepted democratic standards as well.

Pakistan on getting its independence from the British Raj inherited an adversarial judicial system based on Anglo Saxon Laws. It has shown little change since then. This system has failed to deliver to the people at the grass root level. It has inbuilt technicalities and is prone to delays. It is almost impossible to get justice during one's life time after filing a case for any relief. Unfortunately no exercise has been made to improve it and to make it inexpensive, speedy and user friendly for the majority. The court's language is neither local nor national. People also have serious reservations on efficiency and capacity of their presiding officers. There is no proactive, quick and cost effective dispute resolution mechanism at the grass root level to cater for the needs on the subject; therefore common people have lost confidence in the system. I will not hesitate to observe with caution that if political leadership of the country does not take on this egregious issue seriously there will be a complete collapse of the system leading to anarchy. Any improvement in legal and judicial institutions especially in justice delivery system promotes the rule of law and good governance which is a sine qua non requirement for sustainable development.

Supporters of status quo argue that increase in the institution of cases before the existing courts shows public confidence in the existing court system. In fact this is the dilemma of people of this country. They have no choice but to approach these courts knowing that they would not get justice from them during their life time. Had there been an alternative system of dispute resolution in the country their choice for the courts would have been the last one. The Punchayt/Jirga system though in vogue in the country for centuries and serving as an alternative platform for resolving internal disputes amongst communities and their members at the grass root level has been declared illegal by the courts and is losing its credibility.

For this reason, majority of population does not get justice in an effective and speedy manner, on one hand, and there appears no move to bring about a paradigm shift, on the other. It is said that an increase in judges' strength is the only solution of the problem. This paradigm has made all the past initiatives and reforms in the judicial sector ineffective. Billions of rupees have been spent since decades to improve the system but the status quo prevails. An outdated system cannot be made productive through any investment. The loss of billions of rupees in the name of reforms such as "Access to Justice Program" is a criminal act of the rulers of the particular time. If an increase in the number of judges could result in access to justice for the masses perhaps India would have been the first to follow suit, therefore it has introduced "Lok Adalats" and "Court Annexed Mediation Centers" as an Alternative Dispute Resolution mechanism to complement and strength entheir court system.

Now, the question of vital importance is how the State can fulfil its constitutional obligation to provide a system for the masses in Pakistan to get access to justice to meet their need of resolution of disputes under the concept of Primary Justice System which should not only be effective, efficient, inexpensive but also user friendly within their cultural bounds?

Primary justice system helps communities to live in peaceful coexistence. (http://www.ccip-lilongwe.org) Primary justice is synonymous to primary health facility in the healthcare sector. People in case of any sickness do not immediately consult any specialist but they first try self medication and if it does not work then they go to their nearby poly clinic or general practitioner and as a last resort when all their earlier efforts fail, they go to specialists or hospitals as in door patients. "In health we recognize the wisdom of having general practitioners, community nurses, midwives and a primary care system which focuses on catching problems early, treating minor illnesses and keeping people healthy so they stay clear of hospital. Justice needs GPs. It needs a system that stops problems before they start - that catches symptoms and dispenses fixes that keep the community healthy and whole. This must be local, because it must be what the community needs, depending on what that community is like. It must depend on local knowledge and local people who know your street, your neighbour, your history and your family".( http://www.lgiu.org.uk )

In legal sector also a person in need of legal assistance before going to the court, should have a facility of legal clinic where his problem can be tackled at the local level in his village or town without resorting to the formal court system. At present he can only approach the formal court system without resorting to an alternative way. When legal clinics will be available he can resort to them for the resolution of the dispute through ADR mechanism i.e. informal arbitration, conciliation and mediation. Most of the disputes will be resolved at the inception at the local level inexpensively and swiftly without burdening the formal courts. These clinics can be established at local council level under our local body laws for which proper legislation can be made in support of the system by the provincial assemblies. The huge lawyers' fraternity mostly belonging to rural areas can be best utilized for these legal clinics on regular basis. Their connections with their local communities can be utilized to understand the real issues between the parties/disputants and enforce credibility and successful implementation of settlements. The local village heads and other educated persons of the area including women folk can also be utilized along with the members of legal fraternity wherever needed. A brief training from our Federal and Provincial judicial academies or at the law colleges in informal arbitration, mediation and conciliation would only be required for their capacity building. Civil society organizations and Non Governmental Organizations working in the legal field can also play their important roles in this area. A fee structure for the staff of these legal clinics can be a good incentive for rendering their services. In this way a platform can be made available for inexpensive and speedy justice at the grass root level to the needy people. This will improve the quality of life of our people, on one hand and improve the governance level in the country, on the other. Besides this our legal fraternity at large will be empowered by involving it proactively in the process of justice delivery system. This will also develop an environment befitting for the development of legal profession in the country. As an example I may refer to the honourable Chief Justice of Singapore who in his keynote address on the occasion of announcing work plan, 2013 for subordinate courts, announced the introduction of the Primary Justice Project at subordinate courts level to institutionalize early referral of disputes to ADR before case was filed in court. (www.subcourts.gov.sg).

The honourable Chief Justice of Pakistan who is also an ex-officio Chairman of the Law and Justice Commission of Pakistan may perhaps like to refer this proposal to the Commission for deliberations by the stakeholders and to recommend a comprehensive legislative framework to the provincial assemblies to make the Primary Justice Program a part of our formal judicial system to ensure speedy, inexpensive and effective dispute resolution mechanism at the grass root level and strengthen the country's formal justice delivery system.

Note:- The worthy readers specially from the legal sector may start a debate on the issue to challenge the status quo by presenting a new perspective on the justice system in Pakistan.

ROLE OF JUDICIARY IN DEVELOPING WORLD


ROLE OF JUDICIARY IN DEVELOPING WORLD

By

Mr. Justice Abdus Sattar Asghar,
Judge, Lahore High Court, Lahore

Former U.N. Secretary General Kofi Annan once stated "good governance is perhaps the single most important factor in eradicating poverty and promoting development." Development of a country revolves in seven arenas:

(i) Civil Society, i.e. the way citizens become aware of and raise political issues;

(ii) Political Society i.e. the way social interests are aggregated in politics;

(iii) Economic Society i.e. how state-market relations are structured;

(iv) Legislature; i.e. commands of the sovereign or the Constitution based on the will of the people;

(v) Judiciary i.e. the rules for how disputes are settled;

(vi) Executive i.e. the rules for stewardship of the system as a whole; and

(vii) Bureaucracy i.e. the rules guiding how policies are implemented.

The judicial arena is an integral part of a political process approach to governance, but it is also somewhat different from others.

2. Each society whether developing or developed, requires institutions and structures that can resolve disputes of private or public nature between contending parties. Administration of justice has a key- role in the development of the society. Administration of justice in a society is evolutionary process. In pre-modern societies vital organs that we consider separate today i.e. legislation, implementation and adjudication were controlled by a King, the sovereign authority. As societies became more complex and spanned over larger territories legal system also evolved with the growth of social, political, economic and administrative systems. As this transition continued, old rules were recast in a new combination. Nature became the property; economic relations became contract; and conscience became will and intent. Regardless of trivial differences, the role of law throughout remained subjecting human conduct to the governance of rules. Emphasis therefore remained not only on the rules themselves but also on the ways in which rules were applied in the society. Today we have reached stage that the way judicial institutions operate have an impact on a country's economic and development performance. The legal reforms advance freedom, a crucial and constitutive quality of comprehensive development.

3. Development depends on people being able to enjoy basic legal rights. A recent study of the poor conducted under the auspices of the World Bank confirms that these people have the issues of safety, security and access to justice as high priority. The institutional approach to these dimensions certainly affect development performance. Economic theory suggests that the judiciary might affect economic outcomes. Long time ago Adam Smith argued "a tolerable administration of justice" along with peace and low taxes, was all that was necessary to "carry a state to the highest degree of opulence". Ever-since, however, scholars have argued about the ways in which administration of justice may make a difference to development. The question is, what is more important; upholding property rights, enforcing contracts between economic actors, checking abuses of government power, or ensuring the rule of law? A recent World Development Report brings much of the recent evidence together and concludes that income and the rule of law encompassing the collective importance of property rights, respect for legal institutions and judiciary are highly correlated. It also shows that the absence of formal contract enforcement mechanisms has limited the growth of firms and the development of financial institutions. It envisages a direct relation between independent courts and the expansion of trade. Another study finds a strong co-relation between the legal protections to creditors and investment. Studies of like nature also indicate that widespread legal reforms are not necessary to attract foreign investments and that legal reforms are inherently slow. However, positive impact of solid legal frameworks on economic performance cannot be denied. For instance, work in Asia indicates that legal empowerment can improve circumstances of the poor and that a vibrant civil society and laws that protect it, are important for legal empowerment strategies.

4. Obviously much-vaunted role of economic growth has brought prosperity and high standard of living in all societies, however it has also brought unwanted spill-over effects. Judiciaries have, and will most certainly continue to play a pivotal role both in the development and implementation of fundamental human, social, economic, political, legislative rights and rules for sustainable development in the developing countries through fair, impartial and independent administration of justice. Access to justice, due process, fair trial and judicial autonomy are the key factors to achieve the goal of effective administration of justice to contribute in the development of a country. An independent judiciary is a haul-mark of a developing country.

5. The judiciary acts as an arbitery not only in a dispute between the executive and the individual but also between the executive and the legislator, the executive and the judiciary. Sometimes these disputes may be of a political nature, but Judges cannot avoid making decisions on them. The role of judiciary therefore in Politically Sensitive Areas becomes highly crucial. In politically charged cases the courts have generally shown excessive self-restraint. In a Constitutional State personal and property rights of individuals inter se as well as against the governmental institutions invoke the various jurisdictions of the courts. These rights are to be protected against private as well as public invasion. A threat to fundamental rights may come from private individuals or group of individuals. The constitutional guarantee of rights may be of no avail if private invasion of such rights is allowed. Blackstone in his Commentaries had assumed that fundamental rights were rights not only against government but also against private coercion. The judiciary, as a custodian of the rights of individuals has a duty to protect against private and public encroachment upon these rights. Sometimes threats to fundamental freedom may come from centers of private economic power. Monopolistic tendency in an industry may affect the freedom of trade or right to property to small businessmen. Even certain measures on the part of the government may effect rights of big or small businessmen. Role of judiciary becomes important to resolve such conflicts in developing countries.

6. Corruption is also a human right concern for development and good governance. Corruption hurts the poor disproportionately by diverting funds intended for development, undermining of government's ability to provide basic services, feeding inequality and injustice, and discouraging foreign investment and aid. Judiciary in the developing world has a revolutionary role to control the menace of corruption a crime against society. Growing behaviour of intolerance, fanaticism and terrorism in the developing world is a serious threat to the growth of socio-economic areas. An effective administration of justice on the basis of due process and fair trial is the best answer to such threats to life, liberty, equality and dignity of the human being.

7. Needless to say the judiciary cannot stand aloof and apart from the mainstream of the society. Judges must be sensitive to the "policies and the set economic and social goals of the nation, its economic and political pressures, and social stresses existing within the society". Failure to understand socio-political realities of a particular society may on occasion lead to unhappy conflict between the judiciary on one hand and the executive and general public on the other. At times, Judges may face very difficult and delicate choices. Cases before them may have international political overtones and may involve highly sensitive issues, or policy matters to which a particular nation is fully committed. In such situations, the mark of utility of a judicial decision is not the soundness of its logic, but its role in stabilizing the social and political activity of the nation.

8. In Third World countries judiciary may come across to the most difficult problem of constitutional breakdown seriously affecting its independence in case of imposition of martial law, army rule or declaration of emergency etc. Such unconstitutional or constitutional steps undermine independence of judiciary. Judiciary in developing countries has also to face such legal and political problems. An independent judiciary having the support of public opinion therefore is inevitable to wriggle out from such problems in order to restore and protect the fundamental rights, constitution and democratic political system. Judiciary in developing world cannot remain indifferent to national goals and aspirations. Justice Georges has summed up this perspective quite aptly when he said: "We in the Judiciary have sought without sacrifice of principle, to remain independent though not isolated, impartial but not indifferent, positive but not inflexible." He also said that Judges should lead but not from too far ahead"

BOOKS AND REPORTS CONSULTED

* Human Rights in 21st Century Changing Dimensions: By Gurdip Singh V.K. Ahuja

* The Judiciary and Governance in 16 Developing Countries: United Nations University Survey: By Julius Court, Goran Hyden and Ken Mease

* The Role of the Judiciary in Promoting Sustainable Development: The Experience of Asia and the Pacific: By the Honourable Justice Brian J. Preston Chief Judge of the Land and Environment Court of New South Wales Australia

*. The Independence of the Judiciary: A third World Perspective: By Yash Vyas

*. Corruption in Developing Countries: Its causes and Economic Consequences: By Edgardo Buscaglia, Ph.D. Crime Research Expert., Global Programme against Corruption (GPAC), Centre for International Crime Prevention, Office for Drug Control and Crime Prevention, United Nations Office at Vienna.

Friday, 6 September 2019

DIFFERENCE BETWEEN REJECTION AND RETURN OF PLAINT

DIFFERENCE BETWEEN REJECTION AND RETURN OF PLAINT
RETURN OF PLAINT:-
Order 7 rule 10 of code of civil procedure 1908
The plaint shall at any stage of the suit be returned to be presented to the court in which the suit should have been presented.
PROCEDURE OF RETURN OF PLAINT:-
Order 7 rule 10(2) of code of civil procedure 1908
On return a plaint the judge shall endorse thereon the date of its presentation and return.
REJECTION OF PLAINT:-
Order 7 rule 11 of code of civil procedure 1908
Court may reject the plaint if requirements of law are not fulfilled, rejection can be made on different grounds
i- Plaint not disclosing cause of action
ii- Relief claimed is undervalued
iii- Plaint is insufficient stamped
GROUNDS OF REJECTION OF PLAINT:-
Following are the grounds of rejection of plaint
i- Plaint not disclosing cause of action
ii- Relief claimed is undervalued
iii- Plaint is insufficient stamped

REJECTION OF PLAINT

 REJECTION OF PLAINT....................
Order 7 rules 11, 12, 13.
1- ESSENTIALS CONDITIONS.
(i) If plaint does not show cause of action.
> the court should reject the plaint which is
manifestly meritless and vexatious and
does not disclose cause of acction.
> it is at the time of of institution of suit, if
occured during pending may not reject.
> for this purpose the court only looked
into and nothing else.
(ii) Relief claimed is undervalued.
> if is under valued and court given time to
correct the same.
> if plaintif fails to do so,the plaint rejected.
> if corrected valuation is exceeded
jurisdiction, the court return the plaint
under rule 10.
> section 149 is also applicable.
(iii) Suit is insufficiently stamped.
> determine correct valuation but plaint is
written upon insufficiently stamped.
> court granted time but plaintif fails to do.
> diff. b/w clauses B and C is that former
applies where suit is undervalued, the
later pre-supposes correct valuation.
(iv) When suit is Barred by law.
> the suit appears to be prima facie barred
by law.
> instances as suits barred by law.
> time barred, bad for multi ferious.
not sending prior notice, by res
judicata, by limitation, by sec 10,
12(2), ord 2 r 2, ord 9 r 9, ord 23
r 1, etc etc..
2- PROCEDURE OF COURT ON REJECTING
PLAINT. (rule 12)
> when plaint rejected the court shall
record record the effects and reasons.
3- WHEN PLAINT IS REJECTED, THE PLAINTIF
IS NOT PRECLUDED FROM PRESENTING
FRESH SUIT (rule 13).
4- MISCELLENIOUS POINTS OF RULE 11.
> Its mandatory in nature.
> Its not applicable in pauper application.
> its applicable at any stage even before
pronouncing of judgment.
> action can be taken as sou motu.
> appeal lies, revision not lie, review also
lie in appropriate cases.

Concept Of “Zero FIR” – You Can File An FIR Anywhere!

Concept Of “Zero FIR” – You Can File An FIR Anywhere!
There is a concept of “Zero-FIR”. It means that a FIR can be filed in any police station (i.e.: irrespective of place of incident/jurisdiction) and the same can be later transferred to the appropriate Police Station. However policemen usually deny knowing about “Zero FIR” and direct the complainant to concerned Police Station.”
Concept of Zero FIR: Explained
Empowers police to proceed with a case where FIR has been filed within the territorial jurisdiction of a particular Police Station where the incident occurred.
So what about FIRs which fall outside the territorial jurisdiction of a particular Police Station?
Looking at the provisions of Criminal Procedure Code, if FIR is not filed within territorial jurisdiction of a concerned Police Station, the Station House-in-Charge (SHO) of that particular Police Station cannot proceed with further investigation of the case and the FIR should be filed with a Police Station which has territorial jurisdiction to act over the case. But practically it is not always possible to adhere to the exact wordings of Criminal Procedure Code
For example: If a person visits Police Station informing the police that his friend was murdered on the road (cognizable offence). Incidences like this require immediate action on part of the police (like collecting samples, getting information from eye witnesses, etc.); in such a situation police cannot excuse themselves saying that the case does not fall within their jurisdiction. This will hamper the very objective of the police force that is ‘to maintain law and order’. But at the same time it is mandatory to adhere to statutory regulations, so after investigation is over, if the Investigating Officer arrives at the conclusion that the cause of action for lodging the FIR has not arisen within his territorial jurisdiction, then he is required to submit a report and forward the case to the Magistrate empowered to take cognizance of the offence and must also submit all the materials including copy of FIR, collected sample of evidence and detailed report of the inquiry done till the date the case is transferred to the concerned Police Station.
The Supreme Court held that, Police can investigate the case, which does not fall under their jurisdiction.
Can a party take undue advantage of filing a Zero FIR?
Yes a party can exploit the provisions of Zero FIR. The main reason that can lead to undue advantage in case of Zero FIR is that outcome of criminal case mainly depends on the preliminary investigation carried out at the beginning of the case.
Transferring the FIR at the later stage may adversely affect the case as the opposite party may file an FIR at the Police Station of its choice and by getting the investigation report made in their favor.
Other drawback of filing a Zero FIR is that Police Station not having territorial jurisdiction over the case, may lodge the FIR for satisfaction of the complainant, but may immediately transfer the FIR to the concerned Police Station without making any preliminary inquiry in the case.
What happens where there are multiple territorial jurisdictions?
Example: A woman is mentally harassed for dowry in Karachi(place where she stayed with her husband and in-laws) and is also physically tortured at Hyderabad(where her parents stay) where she finally succumbed to death.
This is an instance of continuing offence. There is provision under Criminal Procedure Code which expands the horizon of territorial jurisdiction where FIR can be lodged at both the places i.e. either at Hyderabador at Karachi. The concept of continuing offence is different from that of Zero FIR because in the case of continuing offence, there is no need of transferring the FIR from one place to another place as the alleged offence took place at both the places unlike in the case of Zero FIR.
Legal Reference
2010 CLC 258 Lahore

Res-subjudice (Stay of Suit)

Res-subjudice (Stay of Suit)
Section 10 of the CPC deals with the concept of ‘res subjudice’. The Latin world ‘ Res ’ means ‘ thing ’ and ‘ sub judice ’ meand ‘ under a judge ’ or ‘ under determination of a court. ’ Technically the term ‘ res subjudice ’ means stay of suit. In other words, a suit is to be stayed the subject matter of which is already a matter of issue in another suit. Section 10 specifies that no court shall proceed with the trial of any suit in which the matter in issue is also directly and substantially in issue in a previously instituted suit between the same parties and that the court in which the previous suit is pending is competent to grant the relief claimed.

Conditions of Res-subjudice: – For the application of section 10 following conditions have to be fulfilled
Two or more suits
All suites are pending
Same Parties
Same Subject-matters
Same Cause of Action
All suits are instituted in Bangladesh
Res Judicata
Section 11 of the CPC deals with the concept of ‘res judicata. The term ‘ res judicata ’ is Latin in language and has been borrowed from Roman Law. Ballentine in his Law Dictionary defines it as too connote ‘a thing settled by judicial dicisions’.
Thus ‘res judicata’ means a final judicial decision of a court of competent jurisdiction, once pronounced between parties/litigant, cannot be contradicted by any one, as against any other of such parties, in any subsequent litigation between the same parties, respecting the same subject – matter. It is founded on the principle that there should be an end to the litigation as to any issue between the same parties when once that issue has been directly and substantially determined between them by a court of competent jurisdiction.
Conditions of Res–Judicata: – Section of the CPC embodies the doctrine of Res judicata and the conditions for its application are as follows:
Two or more suits
One suit already been decided
Same Parties
Same Subject-matters
Same Cause of Action
All suits are instituted in Bangladesh
Distinction between Res-Subjudice and Res- Judicata

There are some important distention between Res-Subjudice and Res- Judicata. There are Following:-
1.In case of Res-Subjudice, there must be two suits, one previously instituted where as incase of Res- Judicata there must be an end to litigation.
2. In case of Res-Subjudice, the matter in issue in both the suits must be substantially the same. On the other hand, the matter directly and substantially in issue in the subsequent suit must have been directly and substantially in issue in the former suit either actually or constructively.
3.In case of Res-Subjudice, the previously instituted suit must be pending in the same court in which the subsequent suit was brought or in a different court having jurisdiction to grant the relief claimed. On the contrary, the former suit must have been a suit between the same parties or between parties under whom they or any of them claim.
4.In case, of Res-Subjudice, such parties must be litigating in both the suits under the same title. In case of Res- Judicata, such parties must have been under the same title in the former suit.
5.In case of Res-Subjudice, both the suits must be between the same parties or their representatives. On the other hand, a final decision of a concrete issue between parties.
Constructive res judicata
The rule of direct res judicate is limited to a matter actually in issue alleged by one party and either denied or admitted by the other party expressly or impliedly. But the rule of constructive res judicata, and provides that if a plea could have been taken by a party in a proceeding between him and his opponent, he should not be permitted to take that plea against the same party in a subsequent proceeding with reference to the same subject – matter.
The clearly is opposed to considerations of public policy on which the doctrine of res judicata is based and would mean harassment and hardship to the opponent. Besides, if such a course is allowed to be adopted, the doctrine of finally of judgments pronounced by courts would also be materially affected.
Thus, it helps in raising the bar of res judicata by suitably construing the general principles of subduing a cantankerous litigant. That is why this rule is called constructive res judicata, which, in reality, is an observed by Somervell, L. J. : “ I think that … it would be accurate to say that res judicata ….. is not confined to the issues which the court is actually asked to decide, but that it covers issues or facts which are so clearly part of the subject – matter of the litigation and so clearly could have been raised that it would be an abuse of the process of the court to allow a new proceeding to be started in respect of them.”
Res judication between co – plaintiffs
Just as a matter may be res judicata between co – defendants, so also it may be res judicata between co – plaintiffs, if there is a conflict of interest between plaintiffs and it is necessary to resolve the same by a court in order to give relief to a defendant, and the matter is in fact decided, it will open as res judicata between co – plaintiffs in the subsequent suit.
Res judicata between co – defendants
As a matter may be res judicata between a plaintiff and a defendant, similarly, it may be res judicata between co – defendants and co – plaintiffs also. Adjudication will operate as res judicata between co – defendants if the following conditions are satisfied.
There must be a conflict of interest between co – defendants.
It must be necessary to decide that conflict in order to give relief to the plaintiff.
The question between co – defendants must have been finally decided, and
The co – defendants were necessary or proper parties in the former suit.
If the conditions are satisfied, the adjudication will operate as res judicata between co– defendants.
Res Judicate and Estoppel:

Estoppel is not the same thing as res judicata. The difference lies in the following points:
Whereas estoppel is a part of the law of evidence and proceeds upon equitable principle of altered situation, the doctrine of res judicata belongs to procedure and is based on the principle that there must be an end to litigation.
Estoppel prohibits a party from providing anything which contradicts his previous declarations or acts to the prejudice of a party, who, relying upon them, altered his position; res judicata, on the other hand, prohibits the court from enquiring into a matter already adjudicated.
Estoppel shuts the mouth of a party whereas res judicata ousts the jurisdiction of the court.
Thus it appears that res judicata precludes a man averring the same thing twice over in successive litigations, while estoppel prevents him saying one thing at one time and the opposite at another.
Lis-Pendens
The literal meaning of the maxim lis pendens is a suit under consideration of any court of law. This principle is based on the maxim ‘liti pendete nihil innovetur’ (meaning thereby, nothing can be introduced during the pendency of a suit).
Section 52 of the Transfer of Property Act 1882 which lays down the principle runs as follows:
During the pendency in any Court in Bangladesh of any suit or proceedings which is not collusive and in which any right to immoveable property is directly and specifically in question, the property cannot be transferred or otherwise dealt with any party to the suit or proceeding so as to affect the rights of any other party thereto, under any decree or order which may be made therein, except under the authority of the Court and on such terms as it may impose.
Explanation : For the purpose of this section, the pendency of a suit or proceeding shall deemed to comments from the date of the presentation of the plaint or the institution of the proceeding in a Court of competent jurisdiction, and to continue until the suit of proceedings has been disposed of by a final decree or order and complete satisfaction or discharge of such order has been obtained, or has become unobtainable by reason of the expiration of any period of limitation prescribed for the execution thereof by any law for the time being in force.
1) The conditions for the application of the doctrine are as follows:
2) Pendency of suit or proceeding.
3) Competency of Court to decide suit or proceeding.
4) Suit or proceeding not to be collusive.
5) Some right to immovable property must be directly and specifically involved in that suit or proceeding.
6) One of the parties to the suit must have transferred or disposed of the property.
7) Such transfer or disposal must affect the rights of the other party.
The effect of the application of the doctrine is that it does not negative the conveyance but it remedies it subject to the rights of parties to the litigation. In a series of other cases it was held that the doctrine of Lis-Pendens is binding upon the purchaser pendente lite and the decision of the pending litigation is binding upon them (Party to transaction).

Territorial and Pecuniary Jurisdiction of the Civil Courts.

Territorial and Pecuniary Jurisdiction of the Civil Courts.
1. Introduction
• The court’s jurisdiction is most important concept in law because it directly relates to the powers and authorities of the court that which kind of issues among the state and its citizens a court can decide under the light of rules and regulations of the state. Civil courts can decide only the civil suit such as marriage and divorce related issues or family relates issues etc.
2. Relevant Provision
• Section 6 and 15 of the CPC deals with territorial and pecuniary jurisdiction of the civil courts.
3. Definition of Jurisdiction
• Jurisdiction is meant an official power and authority of the courts to make a legal decision on the issues after hearing
4. Territorial Jurisdiction
Territorial jurisdiction of the court is being explained as under according to the subject matter. Because every court is not empowered to hear every kind of case.
1. Territorial jurisdiction
• Territorial Jurisdiction of the court is such authority of the court which can be used by the court to decide the issue within specified geographical territory. If the court does not have territorial jurisdiction, in this case court does not have the authority to make a decision
 Example
• For example, High Court of two different provinces such as Punjab and KPK may have same powers in their respective provinces, but are divided on the basis of area. Cases of the Punjab will be filed in Punjab High Court and cases of KPK will be filed in the KPK High Court.
2. Place of suing
Following are the places of suing.
1. Plaintiff can sue on the place where wrong was committed
2. Plaintiff can sue on the place where wrong doer resides
3. Plaintiff can sue on the place where wrong doer does his business
 Example
• If Y who is living in Islamabad and gives a defamatory statement against Z who is living in Lahore, in this case it is the discretion of Z who may sue Y either in Islamabad or in Lahore
5. Pecuniary jurisdiction
Pecuniary jurisdiction of the court is being explained as under according to the monetary value of the suit. Because every court is not empowered to hear every kind of case.
1. Pecuniary jurisdiction
• Pecuniary means 'related to money'. Pecuniary jurisdiction of the court is such authority of the court where pecuniary (monetary) limits on the jurisdiction of a court are defined by the law. Under this jurisdiction all courts can decide the issues according to their defined limits.
2. Pecuniary jurisdiction of civil judges
Following are the pecuniary jurisdiction of the civil judges according to their grades or classes under West Pakistan civil court Ordinance ll of 1962.
A. Civil judge of 1st class
• Jurisdiction of civil judge of 1st class is defined to exercise his powers on original suits where there is no limit has been defined
B. Civil judge of 2nd class
• Jurisdiction of civil judge of 2nd class is defined to exercise his powers on the suits which are valued of up to 50,000
C. Civil judge of 3rd class
• Jurisdiction of civil judge of 3rd class is defined to exercise his powers on the suits which are valued up to 200,000
6. Other kinds of jurisdiction of courts
Following are the other kinds of jurisdiction of civil courts
1. Personal jurisdiction
• Personal jurisdiction is also known as in personam jurisdiction. Where a court is requested to determine the defendant's rights or obligations and court has such powers to determine the right and obligations, it is called personal jurisdiction.
2. Appellate jurisdiction
• Appellate jurisdiction of the court is a power of a higher court to review the decisions of lower courts when aggrieved person make an appeal for it.
3. Subject matter jurisdiction
• Subject-matter jurisdiction of the court is an authority of a court to hear cases of some specific type of subject matter such as bankruptcy court can only hear the cases of bankruptcy and terrorist court can hear the cases of terrorism only.
7. Conclusion
• To conclude i can say that according to the laws of the state, the state has defined the jurisdiction of the civil courts, all the civil courts have been restricted to hear all kind of cases before them and a court cannot decide a case outside of its jurisdiction. There are multiple kinds of jurisdiction in the law such as pecuniary, territorial, personal, appellate and subject matter jurisdiction

Tuesday, 12 February 2019

GENERAL GUIDELINES TO CONVEYANCING

GENERAL GUIDELINES TO CONVEYANCING

Q. Enumerate and explain important parts of an 'Indenture'. OR A. Write notes on the following,
I. Consideration   II. Conveyancing   III. Recitals   IV. Parcels   V.Habendum

1. INTRODUCTORY NOTE:

The deed is a written document which is signed and attested if necessary and delivers such documents, intended to perform an act with respect to property and to form an authentic record of transactions. In England the technical word used to word deed is" indenture". In Pakistan word "deed" & "indenture" do not find any place in the statutes and word "instruments' or 'documents' have been used instead. When the single party executes the deed, it is called a 'deed poll'.

2. LANGUAGE AND CONTENTS OF DEEDS:

No particular form or language has been prescribed in law for drawing up of deeds. The only requirement is that the intention of the parties must be clearly stated and the wording shall be unambiguous and clear.

3. COMPONENT PARTS OF THE DEED:

I. Description OF THE DEED:

It means what type of transaction is to be drawn on the paper, for example mortgage deed, deed of sale, deed of mortgage, gift deed, deed of exchange etc. It is a custom to write the title in capital words though it is not necessary.

II. DATE OF EXECUTION:

This is the date on which deed is going to be written and executed.

III. NAME AND DESCRIPTION OF PARTIES:

The names of all the parties to the deed, their parental name, their residing address and their ID card numbers are written under this head.

IV. RECITALS:

Recitals mean narration of the facts. Recitals are of two kinds,

i. NARRATIVE:

Narrative recitals are those recitals which describe the past history of the property which is under transfer.

ii. INTRODUCTORY:

Introductory recitals are those recitals, which explain the motive for the execution of the deed.

V. TESTATUM:

It is witnessing clause necessary before the writing of the operating words of the deed. For example "this deed witnesseth as follows".

VI. CONSIDERATION:

Mentioning of consideration is necessary in the deed. It ascertains the stamp duty on the deed. Acknowledgement of receipt of consideration may be embodied in the deed itself instead of giving a separate receipt.

VII. OPERATIVE WORDS:

These are the words, which set-forth the main object of writing of deed and it gives effect to the transaction. It is customary to mention that the transaction has been entered into by the both parties without any force, coercion, undue influence, and misrepresentation.

VIII. PARCELS:

Parcel is the description of the location of the property transferred. For example house A which is to be transferred, has a ground on his right side, has Zahid Hussain's house on left side, a vacant plot on his backside and a road on the face of it.

IX. EXCEPTIONS & RESERVATIONS:

Exceptions are the rights in existence necessary for completion of the transact on. Reservation is something not in existence at the date of transaction but is duly created by grant such as the right of way etc.

X. HABENDEM:

It means "to have" and "to hold" clause and its purpose is to name again the transferee and to define the estate and the amount of interest taken by transferee.

XI. COVENANTS:

It simply means the terms of agreement which may be entered into by the parties signing the deed.

XII. TESTIMONIUM AND ATTESTATION:

Testimonium sets-forth the fact of the parties signing the deed. For example, signed at Lahore etc this 1st day of August, 2007. Attestation sets-forth the facts of the witnesses attesting the execution of the deeds. For example,

                     (Sgd) AB                                                                                                       (Sgd) AB
                                                                                                                                                        
                     Witness                                                                                                        Witness
       ____________________                                                                           ____________________
       ____________________                                                                           ____________________